Sensible Token Classification

Tokens are not one undifferentiated asset class. Let the nature of the asset be the starting point for determining what regulations apply to a token.

Physical asset tokens

Representing real world items

Shoes

Shoes

Light regulation
Medicines

Medicines

Moderate regulation
Poisons

Poisons

Heavy regulation

Intangible asset tokens

Representing things of value we can’t touch

Art

Art

Light regulation
Patents

Patents

Moderate regulation
Financial instruments

Financial instruments

Heavy regulation

Service tokens

Representing services

Gig tickets

Gig tickets

Light regulation
Insurance

Insurance

Moderate regulation
Airline services

Airline services

Heavy regulation

Stablecoins

Designed to be stable against fiat currency.

USDC

USDC

PAXG

PAXG

DAI

DAI

BUSD

BUSD

Some stablecoins fit within existing regulations. Others may require bespoke regulatory treatment.

Native DLT tokens

The heartbeat of blockchain.

BTC

BTC

AVAX

AVAX

ETH

ETH

SOL

SOL

Native DLT tokens do not require a new regulatory regime - but their global tradability and transferability do raise questions of market integrity.

With that said...

Most tokens represent things that already exist, and they can be regulated — or not regulated — in the exact same way: same asset equals same risk, which results in same regulation. The legal and regulatory treatment should become readily apparent upon an analysis of the functions and features of a particular token. There are many forms by which an asset can be represented. DLTs are just one of the newest. There is no need to abandon sound principles when a new technology for representing things comes along. Discover more:

A Sensible Token Classification System — as seen in Novum Insights

Understanding and Classifying Blockchain Tokens — as seen in The International Journal of Blockchain Law by the GBBC (p. 18-22)